Dawn Reader

Dawn Reader
from Open Door Coffee Co.; Hudson, OH; Oct. 26, 2016

Saturday, April 10, 2021

Cancel Shakespeare? FIE!

 


I've read about this now and then—about the "canceling" of Shakespeare. Not entirely, of course, but certain plays for certain reasons (say, The Merchant of Venice or Othello), and the other day this article popped up in my email: "The Case Against Shakespeare," a piece by a teacher and a huge fan of the Bard.  (Link to article.)

The writer is suggesting that we should put off teaching any Shakespeare until, oh, senior year in high school—teach some sonnets earlier but not a full-length play.

I disagree with that strongly (as many of my former students will recall). I taught plays to 8th-12th graders and had a lot of fun doing so—having more fun the more I learned myself about the Bard and his times.

I taught The Taming of the Shrew, Much Ado About Nothing, Julius Caesar, Hamlet, and Othello (this last, to college freshmen). And as the years went on, I began to expand how I approached each play.

I should back up and say that my own high school (and early college) experiences were not especially good. Caesar and Macbeth in high school, Macbeth again my freshman year in college. In none of those classes did the teachers make much of an effort to introduce us to the Bard or his times. Basically, we were on our own with the footnotes (and, okay, Cliffsnotes). As a result I got no true "feel" for the plays—or the writer—at all.

So when I began teaching Shrew to my 8th graders (1985-86) I was pretty ignorant myself about all of it. But teaching, as I wrote here the other day, I'd always seen as a chance to educate myself as well as the kids.

And so I did.

Before starting I would tell them that if Shakespeare were to somehow appear at their lunch table, he wouldn't understand a thing of what they were talking about or doing. In order to communicate with us, he would have to learn about us and our world.

So we have to do the same with his language and his world.

Soon, my 8th graders and I were devoting an entire 9-week marking period to the enterprise—learning about Elizabethan music, games (we played some), religion, history, schooling, dress, family life, etc. By the time we started the play, we were pretty much imbedded in the era—a couple of years I even required them to use forms of thee and thou when they spoke in class.

Then we read the play aloud, together, pausing for discussion and explanation, before we saw the film. And every year—every single year—I caught things I’d missed on previous readings—and kids would say things I’d never thought of. I found it exciting.

With Hamlet, in my final years, I stopped when we finished Act IV, saw the movie (Mel Gibson!), before going through Act V. I didn't want to spoil the end for them before they saw it.

Oh, and I loved beginning to read the play with them. The first line is “Who’s there?” And I would stop the reading and say, “Man, this is a hard play!”

The other thing we did regularly was memorize lines. I  asked my 8th graders to memorize one of two sonnets—“Shall I Compare Thee to a Summer’s Day” and “My Mistress’ Eyes Are Nothing Like the Sun.” And, also, a passage from the play we were reading.

My eighth graders also had to recite that sonnet in front of the class. One year I had a young man who refused to do it—willing to take an F. I decided to bribe him. I offered him a dollar. No. Five dollars. No—and by now his classmates were calling out, “Come ON, man.” I took a look in my wallet. “Ten dollars.” By now there was near-chaos in the class. So he stood and walked to the front of the room while the other kids cheered.

He stumbled through it—but completed it all right. I had the ten waiting for him.

He refused it. “Nah,” he said. “It’s Shakespeare.”

Indeed it is.

Friday, April 9, 2021

Close to Voting Time


In yesterday's mail my absentee ballot arrived for the May election here in Ohio. There's a local issue I'm really going to support and vote for: funding for the public library. How could I ever vote against that?

I couldn't.

My parents (both teachers) taught me never to vote against a school issue. I never did. And, later, when I was a teacher myself, I saw the consequences of NO votes. I didn't just see them; I felt them--as did the students. Larger classes, decline in funding for supplies and textbooks and school activities, etc. Some years it was awfully grim.

There's a lot of talk these days (talk is a generous word for some of the vitriol I read in newspapers, see online and on TV) about making voting more difficult in order to, you know, eliminate voter fraud--a condition that all reasonable research reveals just doesn't really exist--certainly not in the massive numbers that losers of elections claim. And much (most?) of what occurs is accidental.

If I lived in some of these states that are clamping down on voting, I couldn't vote. There is no way I could stand in line for hours; I couldn't really stand in line for minutes. I grow so dizzy so fast that I would hit the floor very quickly. And, of course, I think about my mother, who died at 98, who was basically immobile the latter years of her life but still voted absentee all those years. As did my father, who died at 87 and had the same voting experiences.

I think of people who don't have easy access to transportation, who can't get away from work to stand for hours somewhere, of people who are out of town--or the country--on business, of people who ... those pictures I’ve seen on the news of people in wheelchairs in endless lines were just wrenching ...

Meanwhile, I think with gratitude how easy Ohio makes it for voters--and I think of my mother and father, totally immobile, still sharp mentally, lying on their backs in their Massachusetts care facility and filling in their ballots over the years. And how grateful I am that Massachusetts made it easy for them to so because that state still believes in democracy--and democracy means "majority rule," not “minority manipulation.”

And, of course, many of the politicians who bellow about “in-person voting” do not vote in person.

Of course we need to make elections secure (we do)—of course we must make certain that our results are as accurate as possible.

But we also must make certain that it is not an ordeal to vote. Yes, it’s a privilege, but it’s also a right. And not everyone has the leisure, the transportation, the health, etc. to comply with our ever-more draconian voting regulations. It’s hard enough trying to overcome the gerrymandering of which both parties have been guilty.

 

Thursday, April 8, 2021

Learning to Write from My Students


In the 1972-73 school year, I was very busy: I was teaching English/Language Arts full-time to 7th graders at the Aurora (Ohio) Middle School, Joyce and I were dealing with our little boy (born in July 1972), and both of us were part-time students in grad school.

So it's no real surprise that one day that year--one Friday--I arrived at school without a lesson plan in mind or on paper.

But as I was walking to my first class, quaking, I got an idea. And after I entered the room, took attendance, quieted the kids down, etc., I unloaded my idea on the kids in words like this: "Today I'm going to ask you to write about anything you want to."

Strange looks.

"Anything?" asked one boy who already had some naughty ideas.

"Anything that's rated G or PG," I said. "Nothing more." The boy's face faded.

Lots of questions about grades and length.

Then I surprised them (and me): "And I'm going to do it, too."

Looks and sounds of surprise.

"We’ll write for about 30 minutes," I said, "then volunteers will read aloud."

And thus was born what soon we were all calling "Friday Writing." And it turned out to be one of the most enjoyable days of the week--for most if not all of us.

Let's back up now. As I said, I was working on my master's degree at Kent State--and soon my Ph.D. I was writing scholarly papers for class--the kind of pieces that were predictably arranged: thesis statements, topic sentences, introductions and conclusions. And I have to say that I didn't like that kind of writing. I didn't know what I did like, but I knew it wasn't that.

So that first day we all sat at our desks, notebooks open, and slowly began. I started writing about my boyhood and found the words flowing out as if I'd turned on a spigot. Most of the kids were seemingly having the same experience. A few were having trouble, and one of them asked me, "I can't think of what to write about."

And I replied, "Write what it feels like when you don't know what to write about."

And so he did. (And so I did a number of times.)

I have to say I was often dazzled by what the kids did. Some wrote diaries; some wrote continuing stories; some wrote letters; some wrote poems.

And then I did, too.

I started a YA novel called Bob the Slob, finished it about a year later, and, later on, I revised it and published in on Kindle Direct, where it still abides. Lonely.

In 1978, Ph.D. complete, I took a job at Lake Forest College, decided I missed middle school kids a lot, resigned, tried to get back to Aurora: no openings. So both Joyce and I took jobs at Western Reserve Academy until a job back in Aurora did open up; I snatched it.

Right away I started Friday Writing again, but didn't always do it on Fridays, so I began calling it Free Writing, a practice I continued until the mid-90s, when Ohio introduced a "proficiency test" in writing, a test that was very formulaic, and so I could no longer devote 20% of our week to the "free" kind.

I was near retirement by then and decided I would take it ASAP: I just didn't like what these tests were forcing me to do--and be.

Anyway, all those years had really relaxed my writing, had shown me that I could entertain and instruct my students--and vice-versa.

From their examples, I learned to "loosen up," to find what sort of writing I was good at and to try to get better. (This blog, really, is a result of their alteration of the Writing Me.)

Oh, and I almost forgot: In May 1976 I published the cover story "When Kids Are Free to Write" in English Journal, the official publication of the National Council of Teachers of English--and (brag, brag) won their writing award for the year. My mom was thrilled: She had published in that journal, too!

Oh, and I almost forgot: In May 1976, when that journal arrived at our house in Kent, my wife drove it and our three-year-old son over to Aurora Middle School and brought it to my classroom. I stopped class. Told the kids what it was. Not one of them had ever heard of English Journal.

And so it goes as one begins to understand modesty, humility. My students had to teach me.

Wednesday, April 7, 2021

Educating Myself While Teaching



Here's a confession: When I began teaching in 1966 at age 21, I didn't know a lot.

Here's another confession: When I finished teaching in the spring of 2011, I still didn't know a lot.

Oh, sure, I knew more than I'd known in 1966, but considering all there is to know in the world, I still didn't know a lot. And still don’t.

But this is what I did, right from the beginning. I looked on teaching as an opportunity to educate my students, sure, but also to educate myself.

In bed at night that first year in my tiny, practically bare apartment in Twinsburg, Ohio, I made myself read an hour each night of U. S. history (I was teaching it to my seventh graders), an hour of important fiction (for I was teaching English, as well). I can remember only one book I read that year, a book about the framing of our Constitution: Miracle at Philadelphia, 1966, by Catherine Drinker Bowen. I think it was in that book that I learned that B. Franklin was opposed to the bald eagle as our national bird; he preferred the wild turkey.

I kept up the reading habit for many years--and it's only accelerated in recent (retired, fairly immobile) times.

But it wasn't just reading. In the summers Joyce and I drove all over the country to see (and photograph) literary sites: authors' homes (and graves), places that were settings for novels. Sometimes one of us would get completely obsessed. Joyce and I drove to see about every place that has anything to do with John Brown, from Missouri to upstate New York; I got so impassioned about Jack London and The Call of the Wild that I went to the Yukon twice, hiked the Chilkoot Trail (prominent in the novella), read all his other books--wrote a couple of my own.

Other obsessions: Anne Frank (went to the Netherlands, saw the place where she hid; went to Germany to see the camp where she died, Bergen-Belsen), Edgar Poe (saw the remaining places where he lived, saw his grave), Mary Shelley (traveled all over England, Wales, Switzerland, Italy in search of the places where she'd been--and places relevant to Frankenstein's creature), etc.

I also tried to read the complete works of the writers I was teaching, including Shakespeare, and Joyce and I saw live productions of every play he wrote. Both of us have been to Stratford-upon-Avon to see the Bard sites there.

I maintain that habit today: If I read something I really like by a writer (Elizabeth Strout, Kate Atkinson, Rachel Cusk, Richard Ford. Maggie O’Farrell, et al.), well, I then proceed to read every other damn thing that writer published.

This continues with mysteries (which I love): Robert B. Parker, Michael B. Connelly, Elmore Leonard, and (recently) Val McDermid—and many others.

And on and on.

I had tremendous fun doing all of this, and I like to think that my students benefitted, as well.

I know that when I was a student, I profited more from teachers who actually practiced what they preached--and who loved doing so—not those who stuck to the same old sagging lesson plan year after year.

Now, unable to do much more (cursed bodies!), I still read several hours a day--reading books I should have read years ago (the complete Leatherstocking Tales, the works of Anthony Trollope, for example), reading book by writers I've always meant to read (In Search of Lost Time, Don Quixote, The Three Musketeers and its sequel, Twenty Years After), reading new writers--at least new to me.

Doing this helps me continue to feel alive--at least above the shoulders.

And it's incredibly touching, too, when friends (Facebook and otherwise) and former students follow a recommendation and dive into the book(s), too—nothing like flailing together through the surging streams.

I feel I remain a teacher--unpaid in money, paid in gratitude--precious to me, life-sustaining for me.

Tuesday, April 6, 2021

Dream, Dream, Dream

 

Don and Phil Everly—
The Everly Brothers

It was almost exactly 63 years ago (I was in 8th grade) when the Everly Brothers released "All I Have to Do Is Dream"--a song that featured some lines that could tell you more than any other thing that the song was not of recent generations: 

I can make you mine, taste your lips of wine
Anytime night or day
Only trouble is, gee whiz,
I'm dreamin' my life away.

Gee whiz? I haven't heard that lately! (Link to song.)

I'm thinking about this song today because I had a weird one last night--a dream, that is. It was one of my I-am-a-teacher dreams--but not much like any of the other hundreds (thousands?) I've had before.

In this one, I woke up late, hopped in the car, and hurried to school. It was not a building I recognized, but I saw some old Harmon School colleagues. I ran inside, and it was not till then that I realized I had not dressed in my "teacher clothes"; instead, I was still in my shorty summer pj's. Light blue and very attractive on me, I must say.

As I hurried down the hall, no one noticed me (whew), but then I saw it was an hour earlier than I'd thought. (But what were all those kids and teachers doing there?)

So I sprinted back out to the car, headed home, dressed, and ... woke up. Relieved ... very relieved.

Now, I will not psychoanalyze myself--nor permit anyone else to do so. It was just a dream, right? Didn't mean anything.

I'm just glad that it wasn't real--that no one noticed me (however that happened). But, lying in bed late last night, I felt that song from Hiram School days surge back into my head--especially that line from the Chorus: "I'm dreamin' my life away."

So it seems.


*Don (1937-)  and Phil (1939-2014) Everly.

Saturday, April 3, 2021

Down in the Valley

 


“Down in the Valley”—a song my father used to sing on our family car trips whenever we descended into a valley. Later, I did the same with my family, though my voice hardly matched my father’s magical, clear, unwavering tenor.

Joyce and I drive “down in the valley” a lot, especially during the snow-less months—the Cuyahoga Valley National Park (see pic above) to see the various wonders—and, often, to visit Szalay’s Farm Market for fresh produce in the spring and summer and fall.

One day, in late March 2014, I was so dazzled by the sights and sites and thoughts, that, when we got home, I started writing lines, which on April 3 I finished and shared with my friends on Facebook. I thought I’d share those lines again today on this blog post, so here they are ...

In the Valley

March 21, 2014

(Cuyahoga Valley National Park)

 

We drive down through the valley on

this day in spring. The snow is gone,

except in places hidden from

the frigid sun—we notice some

between the fallen trees (this snow

a visitor who just won’t go).

But balmy temperatures have not—

so far—here in Ohio—got

a grasp, or efficacious way

to force the breezes to obey

the hopes of men. Not that the air

has any interest, any care,

for what we wish. And Nature takes

her own direction—never makes

an error that she cares about—

does not display a single doubt.

This evening, though, she seems to be

in such a mood as to agree

that maybe it is time—or near

the time—to soften. So the deer

we see there in the meadow seem

more calm tonight, there by the stream.

No jagged sense of panic jars

their movements. Not the passing cars.

No, not the fear of hunger. There 

is hope among the deer. The air

no longer terrifies. And then—

we turn—another road. Oh, when

will spring again commence its reign?

(This end-of-winter sad refrain

so often sung—and often heard—

a vernal plaint from bitter bird.)

And now we’re with the river as,

along the crooked route it has,

we flow, so riverine ourselves,

like minor gods—or river elves.

The absent foliage has made

it visible. The thinner shade

allows the sun in feeble stage

to melt the ice—one way to gauge

the potency of moving streams

that course through life like fluid dreams.

We see, these transmutating days,

effects the sun’s artistic rays

have on the grass, on plants whose leaves

have lingered on the stalk, the sheaves

that never made it from the field—

perhaps their fates were finally sealed

when frost and snow arrived at night

and draped them all in shrouds of white.

This evening light instructs us, views

revealing varied shaded hues

of brown. From chocolate to tan—

a pleasing, subtle, spectral span

across a color often named

with words like “drab.” Who can be blamed?

The color brown elicits no

excitement in the fashion show

that Nature mounts. But here—tonight—

this gentle fading evening light

reminds us of those other names

we use. A word like “bronze” proclaims

that brown has other suits to wear

and does so in this valley where

we see them all—the beige and bay,

the copper, cinnamon. Today

they’re all distinct here in the wood.

Belittled brown’s misunderstood

by those who haven’t seen its hues

so varied in this sunset’s views.

And then we turn toward the west

to see the place where herons nest.

They have a valley rookery

so near the road that we can see

them easily. And traffic stops

to see the birds arrayed in tops

of leafless trees. We marvel how

such slender branches bear the weight

of heavy birds as they create

their nests that soon will hold their young.

And here we are, almost among

these wonders who ignore us all

and thereby hold us all in thrall.

Such birds just seem impossible—

our reason dictates that the pull

of gravity should draw them down—

the way a heavy heart can drown

in sorrow. Yet we see them there

just hanging in the valley air,

surveying limbs where they can land

beside a mate—seems so offhand,

descent onto a perfect space,

insouciant, done with subtle grace.

The birds of course are now in pairs—

the spots they’ve picked are clearly theirs,

and it will not be long until

the eggs arrive, and soon the thrill

of seeing there—high in the trees—

new life. (Oh, there will be unease

among the chicks as they survey

the world below and learn the way

to sway in wind high in a tree,

then spread their wings and find they’re free

to ride the rivers in the air

that flow from here to everywhere.)

With darkness near we leave the nests

and drive away, now grateful guests,

and gradually ascend the rise

while sunset decorates the skies.

We’re silent, knowing river, trees,

and brown and birds are memories.

The snow will fall again this week,

but, later, one of us will speak:

“Let’s drive to see the birds tonight”—

and thus we’ll spend remaining light.

 


Friday, April 2, 2021

The Street Where We Lived


 Did my unusual night restlessness occasion all this?

Last night I awoke with my brain bouncing around with the lyrics (well, some of them) to the song “On the Street Where You Live,” from a Broadway show—but I could just not remember which show it was. Although I was pretty sure it was My Fair Lady, I could not figure which character sang it—not Prof. Higgins and surely not the “I’m Gettin’ Married in the Morning” guy.

So who?

But I didn’t turn on the light and check my phone. I guess I wasn’t that curious!

So in mid-morning a former student from Aurora sent me this full-page article (published this week) about ... the street (and the house) where we once lived. 60 E. Pioneer Trail—the house you see in the pic at the top of those post. (See link to the article.) One of the oldest houses in town, it had remained in the same family until 1990 when Joyce and I bought it and restored a lot of it. It was convenient for us: less than a mile away from the school where I taught, about eleven miles from Hiram College, where Joyce was teaching (with only two stoplights between our house and the college), only a couple of miles away from Anna Maria, the facility where Joyce’s mother was battling Alzheimer’s.

But it was not just a convenience. We loved that house. More than enough room for our books, a small room at the very back, upstairs, that we used for a guest room with its own bath) and for our son when he came home. He lived there for a while after he graduated from college, but then moved over to Kent, where he earned a master’s in journalism and began his career at the Akron Beacon-Journal, which had been the daily newspaper that Joyce and her family had grown up with.

The Aurora Library was right across the street; the neighbors were kind; my students were respectful; the stores were only about a mile away; we could walk to Mickey D’s (and did) in the evening for a Diet Coke. Okay, and some fro-yo.

Seven years later, though, things had changed. I had retired; Joyce’s mother had died; our son was off commencing his own career and life (he would marry two years later); it was now “too much house” for us.

So we found a much smaller place over in Hudson—close enough to the village green that we could walk many of the places we use: bank, coffee shop, bookstore, office supply place, some clothing stores, our dentist, and on and on. And I’d begun teaching again at Western Reserve Academy—only about three blocks away. I almost always walked—or in good weather rode my bike.

We’ve been here more than 23 years now.

The street where we live now is one of the oldest in town, with some of the oldest houses. We can stand out in the yard and see places where John Brown stood. Joyce got so interested in him that she’s written a wonderful book about him (out soon).

Anyway, I sometimes marvel at the connections between my mind and things I’m not aware of at the time. Like the street where we lived—and a Broadway musical.