Wednesday, September 5, 2012
Hope Springs and Life's Winters
First of all--it's not a great film. Not at all. It's more or less an infomercial for self-help books (and their authors) and for marriage counseling, the sort of counseling that sends the patients (clients? what?) off after each session to "practice" doing things--e.g., holding each other in bed. I've not experienced marriage counseling, and I do not in any way want to offend people who have found help there--or who practice the counseling profession (some of my best friends ...)--but I do want to suggest that the script of Hope Springs made it all look kind of simple-minded.
But in Hope Springs, Carrell was totally straight--and perhaps this is why he went for the role. Stephen King wants to write serious novels; J. K. Rowling wants to write for adults; Chris Rock wants to play straight parts; Paul McCartney wants to write for a symphony orchestra; R. L. Stine tried an adult book; William F. Buckley, Jr. wrote a children's book; you see the pattern.
Anyway, here's what I really wanted to get into: I went to the film expecting the worst. As I wrote a week or so ago, there are three large constituencies whom comedians and writers and filmmakers still see as fair targets in comedy: overweight people, stupid people. And old people. (I wrote about the first one not long ago.)
Think of how we picture the old in our films. Remember the grandmother at the table of the famous (?) dinner scene in Wedding Crashers? She said outrageous and raunchy things like Eleanor Roosevelt was a big bull dyke. And think of just about any part Betty White has played in recent years--I'm thinking of her in The Proposal. And think of the countless "dirty old men" who have populated films in recent years. The filmmakers seem to be thinking: Old folks are just like the rest of us; they like dirty talk and sex. But with them it's gross and funny because, you know, they're old! Not often do we see an older adult who has a brain in his head (Karate Kid comes to mind as an exception). Usually, older characters are bigoted, stupid, forgetful, gross (they want sex! yuck!). And how many Viagra/Cialis jokes are there? (And is it a coincidence that Viagra rhymes with Niagara?)
(Shakespeare wasn't above it, that's for sure. Think, for example, of Gremio, the old fool who's pursuing the young Bianca in The Taming of the Shrew.)
So, I was expecting the worst in Hope Springs--more parodies of the older adult, more sex between old people is gross. (That notion, BTW, is born, I think, when it first dawns on us that our parents had sexual relations ... YUCK!)
But I was surprised--happily so. Both Jones and Streep worked hard to bring dignity to their characters--and to show us that physical intimacy between older lovers can be every bit as moving (and uncomfortable and funny) as it is between younger ones. I can't speak to the yuck factor because there were no teens or other young folks in the audience. I'm guessing that during a couple of the make-out scenes, I would have heard that involuntary sound from them, the one that is hard to spell but rhymes with ewe--only more drawn out with a falling inflection. I used to hear it in class now and then when, feeling frisky, I would say something ... inappropriate.
And I'll end with a final scene. One of the last memories I have of my maternal grandparents (he died in 1965, she in 1978) was when I was in high school. They were visiting. Sitting on our couch. He had his arm around her. Her head was on his shoulder. He reached across his body with his other hand to hold hers. I thought it was surprising. But I was wrong. It was a miracle. The one we've named Love.